Game Protectors, the Early Years
by Lt. Tim Huss
Continued
Having received reports of illegal hunting in Idlewild Woods near present day JFK International Airport, Bill Cramer teamed up with Game Protector Joseph Allen to investigate. Interestingly, Joe Allen's father, Thomas Allen, was a Game Protector in Nassau County from March 16, 1911 to January 3, 1929. Bill Cramer had evidently worked closely with the senior Allen over the years.
 
Patrolling Idlewild Woods near Baisley Park, Bill Cramer and Joe Allen discovered Joseph Lentine of Boerum Street in Brooklyn at around 10:00 a.m. in possession of illegal songbirds.that he had apparently shot. While arresting Lentine for this, another shot rang out close by. With Lentine in custody, the two Game Protectors headed off toward the sound of the shot to investigate. Lentine shouted out a warning in Italian, resulting in a series of shots being fired. In the resulting struggle, Bill Cramer was killed instantly by a shotgun blast to the face. The second illegal hunter, later identified as Frank Aldino, was shot in the wrist. Game Protector Joe Allen was severely beaten.
 
Although severely injured, Joe Allen managed to make his way out of the woods onto the road where he was assisted by a passing motorist. New York City Police Officers from three precincts searched the woods that day, attempting to locate the assailants.
 
On October 8, 1929, Frank Aldino was arrested in Newark, New Jersey for the murder of Game Protector William T. Cramer. His defense was that because Cramer and Allen were not in uniform he thought that he was being robbed. He also stated that the shotgun had discharged accidentally. On the following day, October 9, he was indicted.

The trial commenced on November 26, 1929. It lasted two days, with Joe Allen testifying the first day and Frank Aldino on the second. On November 28th, Frank Aldino was convicted of second degree murder and sentenced to 20 years to life in prison by County Judge Frank Adel of Long Island City. Aldino was remanded to Sing Sing in Ossining, New York.

Bill Cramer was 38 years old at the time he was killed. He was not married, and resided in Ridgewood, Queens. Surely his devotion to duty, having once before been seriously assaulted, has to be recognized as the highest level of valor in the history of natural resource protection.

The story of Bill Cramer reflects the stubborn determination with which the Game Protectors approached their job. Remember that this was a time when laws protecting fish and wildlife were not widely accepted. Game Protectors were resented, and in many instances despised. These early protectors set the tone for what was to become a highly respected law enforcement profession and, despite its small numbers of men, a force to be reckoned with.

Article orginally published in Fall/Winter 2001 issue of "The Conservation Officer."
Home | History | President's Corner | Our Magazine | Scholarships | News | Membership | Cookbook | Links | Contact Us
Copyright © 2001 NYCOA, Inc. All rights reserved.